The Amazing Johnathan: The Comedy Magician and His Documentary
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. How we choose products.
The Amazing Johnathan was an American comedy magician known for a fast, shocking, deliberately sloppy stage act that mixed stand-up with magic gags. He headlined on the Las Vegas Strip for years, kept performing after a serious heart diagnosis, and became the subject of a 2019 documentary. He died in February 2022.
He is not a mentalist, and this page says so early because many people reach it from searches about mind readers and TV magicians. It covers who he was, what the act looked like, his Las Vegas years, the illness, the documentary, and how comedy magic differs from mentalism. It describes the act in general terms and does not explain how any trick worked.
Who Was the Amazing Johnathan?
The Amazing Johnathan was the stage name of John Edward Szeles, a comedy magician from Michigan who became one of the best-known acts on the Las Vegas Strip. The Detroit Free Press says he was born in Detroit and grew up in Fraser, Michigan. He died late on Tuesday, February 22, 2022, at his home in Las Vegas, at age 63; his wife, Anastasia Synn, confirmed the death to the Las Vegas Review-Journal, and FOX Television Stations, citing The New York Times, reported the cause as end-stage heart failure.
Early Years
According to Wikipedia, which cites a 2001 Los Angeles Times profile, he began by performing on the streets of San Francisco in the 1970s. Street performing is a common training ground for comedy magicians, because there is no stage, no lighting and no captive audience, only timing and crowd control.
Television and Touring
Obituaries list HBO's Young Comedians special, a season hosting Merv Griffin's syndicated game show Ruckus, guest spots on Late Night with David Letterman and Fox's Comic Strip Live, and Comedy Central specials including the hour-long Wrong on Every Level. The A.V. Club adds The Weird Al Show, where he was credited as Uncle Jonathan. Chortle notes his many appearances on Hey Hey It's Saturday in Australia.
The Act: Comedy, Shock and Props
Obituaries label him a comic-magician, and that single word is the best summary the sources support. Rolling Stone's obituary headline called him a celebrated comic-magician, and The A.V. Club described him as an unpredictable and inventive magician and stand-up comedian. This section stays at the level of what the genre is and what is publicly said about him.
Comedy First
In a comedy magic act the laugh is the effect. The performer often plays a character who is supposed to be reckless or in over his head, and the audience enjoys the apparent failures as much as the successes. That structure also hides the skill: a trick that looks like a blunder is often rehearsed to the second, a general feature of comic magic and not a claim about any one routine of his.
Props and Shock Gags
He is generally described as a performer who used props and shock for effect. Because bits like that depend on surprise, this page does not describe individual routines or explain how they worked. His Comedy Central specials are the place to look if you want footage, and the broader craft of misdirection and timing is covered on our page about mentalism versus magic.
Las Vegas Years
Las Vegas is where the Amazing Johnathan's career settled. The Detroit Free Press reports that he took a residency at the Golden Nugget in 2001, a run he called the longest-running comedy and magic show in Las Vegas history at 13 years. FOX Television Stations list later stops at the Sahara, the Koval Theater at the Miracle Mile Shops, Bally's and the Rocks Lounge at Red Rock Resort. Exact dates for each venue vary between sources.
A Vegas Regular
A residency in Las Vegas means the same show many nights a week for years. For a comedy magician that is a different job from touring: the act has to hold up for tourists who know nothing about him and for locals who have seen it before. It also explains why his name is tied so closely to the city.
Beyond the Stage
Wikipedia, citing the Las Vegas Sun, describes the Amazing Underground, a members-only indoor drive-in he set up in a Las Vegas warehouse in 2008, and it lists an online talk show, Burn Unit, that he hosted in 2013.
The Diagnosis and the Comeback
The part of his story that reached beyond magic fans was his health. The A.V. Club and Chortle both date a diagnosis of degenerative heart disease to 2007, and The A.V. Club names it as cardiomyopathy. The Detroit Free Press reports that in 2014 he was diagnosed with severe cardiomyopathy and told he had one year to live. This page sticks to what those reports say and does not guess at his medical details.
The 2014 Retirement
FOX Television Stations report that he announced his retirement after the 2014 diagnosis, when doctors gave him 12 to 15 months to live. A clip from 2014, used in the documentary, shows him telling a crowd he had been given a year to live and adding that it was not a joke, as Gray News described it. That remark is his own, and it is not a medical record.
Return to the Stage
He did not stop. The Detroit Free Press describes a return to the stage after he survived longer than doctors expected. Wikipedia, citing an Orlando Sentinel report from April 2017, says he played several shows around the United States that year, with Anastasia Synn, his wife, assisting him on stage and taking over when he tired. The return is the thread the documentary picks up.
The Amazing Johnathan Documentary
The film is a feature documentary about the performer's illness and attempt to keep working. It was written and directed by Ben Berman. According to Wikipedia's page on the film, it premiered at the Sundance Film Festival on January 25, 2019, and features Penn Jillette, Eric Andre, Carrot Top and "Weird Al" Yankovic as themselves.
What the Film Is
It began as a portrait of a comedian facing the end of his career and became something more complicated. Reviews quoted by Wikipedia say the film turns in a direction that surprises even its subject. This page does not describe that turn, because it is the point of the film and it is easy to spoil.
Where to Watch It
After its Sundance premiere the film was bought by Hulu, as TheWrap reported, and it opened in select theaters and on Hulu on August 16, 2019, according to SHOOT. Hulu's old page for the film now redirects to Disney+, which lists it as a 2019 documentary. Availability changes, so check Hulu, Disney+ or a streaming guide before planning an evening around it. A separate documentary, Always Amazing, was released on YouTube in 2019, according to Wikipedia.
What Critics Said
Wikipedia quotes Variety's review saying the director proves to be rather resourceful, and The Hollywood Reporter praising the film as a reminder that documentary work takes more than following someone with a camera. Reviews were not unanimous: Metacritic classes the critical reception as mixed or average.
Comedy Magic vs Mentalism
People often group every stage performer who does odd, uncanny things together. The difference matters. A comedy magician like the Amazing Johnathan sells laughs and shock; the audience knows it is watching tricks. A mentalist presents effects as thoughts, predictions and reactions, and the best ones are careful to say what is entertainment and what is not. Our guide to mentalism versus magic sets out the overlap and the differences in detail.
Another Shock Illusionist
If you like the dangerous edge of his act, the closest profile here is Dan Sperry, a shock illusionist whose act also plays with discomfort. Both are performers whose stage character carries much of the show.
A Hypnosis and Comedy Comparison
For another stage entertainer whose claims are worth a careful look, see Max Major. For the full list of performers covered on the site, start with famous mentalists.
If You Want to Try Magic Yourself
-
A starter set
Penn & TellerBeginner
A beginner kit with a wand and a set of tricks, a safe way to try comedy-style presentation yourself. Nothing here is by the Amazing Johnathan.
Free newsletter
Mentalism, made modern. In your inbox.
Occasional emails from the MentalismPro team: a technique to practice, a routine idea, and the new guides and books worth your time. No spam, unsubscribe any time.